Harness Racing Driver Seeks Another Chance

The intersection between sport, mental health, and the law is once again in the spotlight with the case of harness racing driver Ben Sarina, who is challenging a decision that has barred him from the industry.
Sarina, a lifelong driver, has battled significant mental health difficulties after being permanently warned off by Harness Racing NSW (HRNSW) following the infamous “green light scandal.” His case is now before the NSW Supreme Court, where he is appealing the decision.
A Career on the Line
Sarina was found guilty of falsifying records and was ordered to serve 12 months of community service. However, HRNSW imposed an additional penalty: a permanent warning-off notice, effectively ending his racing career.
While the Honourable Justice Bellew previously ruled that penalties should be proportionate, the broader legal issue now before the Tribunal is whether a regulator can impose indefinite sanctions that exceed the bounds of criminal or civil penalties.
Sarina, who has been around horses since childhood, has expressed that racing is his life and livelihood:
“I would love to have my warning off lifted. I really struggle day to day because I don’t know anything else. I haven’t got a trade. I’m horse mad. I’ve been around horses since I was in nappies.”
Legal and Regulatory Questions
The case raises important questions about procedural fairness and the scope of authority regulators can exercise over individuals’ livelihoods.
- Can a regulator impose sanctions that go beyond a court-imposed sentence?
- How should penalties balance deterrence with rehabilitation?
- What safeguards exist for participants when lifelong bans are imposed?
These questions are not just relevant to the harness racing industry—they highlight broader issues faced by professionals in regulated sectors where governing bodies wield significant power.
The Human Element
The legal issues are complex, but at their heart lies the human impact. Sarina has spoken openly about the toll on his mental health, describing how the ban has left him without purpose and struggling to provide for his family.
Cases like this underline the importance of ensuring that disciplinary action by regulators is fair, proportionate, and consistent with broader principles of justice.
The Outcome
Peter Morris, Special Counsel at Hammond Nguyen Turnbull raised critical questions about:
- The Scope of power under statute.
- The Scope of the rules of racing.
- The application of the rules to a person not participating in harness racing.
Mr Morris was able to successfully argue that Harness Racing New South Wales acted outside their power and that the warning off imposed by HRNSW be removed from his record, highlight that HRNSW can only penalise those participating in the sport.
Looking Ahead
If the matter is appealed to the Supreme Court, its decision will not only determine Sarina’s future but may also shape how regulatory bodies in sport and beyond apply their disciplinary powers in years to come.
At Hammond Nguyen Turnbull, we regularly assist clients navigating disputes with regulators and governing bodies. Whether in sport, employment, or commercial dealings, we advocate for fairness, proportionality, and the protection of rights.

Senior Solicitor
Email: kristen@hntlegal.com.au
Author
List of Services
-
Matthew HammondMatthew Hammond Matthew Hammond
-
Vivian NguyenVivian Nguyen Vivian Nguyen
-
Maria ValenzuelaMaria Valenzuela Maria Valenzuela
-
David CleverleyDavid Cleverley David Cleverley
-
Peter MorrisPeter Morris Peter Morris
-
Andrew PaciniAndrew Pacini Andrew Pacini
-
Marie-Cecilia FerreiraMarie-Cecilia Ferreira Marie-Cecilia Ferreira
-
Jabour HaddadJabour Haddad Jabour Haddad
-
Razeeha ReillyRazeeha Reilly Razeeha Reilly
-
Jack DunnJack Dunn Jack Dunn
-
Melanie KorialMelanie Korial Melanie Korial
-
Albert ThaiAlbert Thai Albert Thai
-
Martin AbdelsayedMartin Abdelsayed Martin Abdelsayed
-
Jamie-Lee MerhiJamie-Lee Merhi Jamie-Lee Merhi
-
Rachel SiewRachel Siew Rachel Siew
-
Dajana PopovicDajana Popovic Dajana Popovic
-
Sarah FoddaSarah Fodda Sarah Fodda
-
Lina VoLina Vo Lina Vo
-
Andre BarkhoAndre Barkho Andre Barkho
-
Alessia GiglioAlessia Giglio Alessia Giglio
-
Alexander BatshonAlexander Batshon Alexander Batshon
-
Gauri KoteraGauri Kotera Gauri Kotera
-
Michelle GalaritaMichelle Galarita Michelle Galarita
-
Bea OctavaBea Octava Bea Octava
-
Georgia MoaitGeorgia Moait Georgia Moait
-
Trisha NguyenTrisha Nguyen Trisha Nguyen
Share to









